article thumbnail

Based on the ESI Protocol, the Limiting “Apex Deposition” Doctrine Applied to Objections to the Designation of a Document Custodian

E-Discovery LLC

It is also not clear to me which party carried the burden of proof under the “apex doctrine.” One recent case placed the burden on the party claiming an exception to the doctrine. 2025 WL 176001, at *1 (cleaned up; citations and quotations omitted). Mayor & City Council of Baltimore v. Lambert , __ Md.

article thumbnail

PROVING THINGS 266: THE BURDEN OF PROOF, HEARSAY EVIDENCE AND WHEN EVIDENCE IS NOT “EXPERT EVIDENCE”: ALSO THE IMPORTANCE OF SERVING A NOTICE OF NON-AUTHENTICITY

Civil Litigation Brief

We are looking, again, at a case where there were issues as to evidence. Part of the defendant's case was that the evidence was not admissible or was hearsay. The defendant's arguments did not prosper. Hearsay is admissible, the real.

Insiders

Sign Up for our Newsletter

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

article thumbnail

How to Prepare for Your First Mock Trial

Jonathan Leach LLC

This includes case briefs, witness statements, exhibits, and relevant statutes or legal precedents. Summarize the facts, jot down key points from witness statements, and organize notes for easy reference later. Then, clarify the burden of proof for each side. Plan your direct and cross-examinations of witnesses.

article thumbnail

CONSIDER A TRIAL CHECKLIST

Plaintiff Trial Lawyer Tips

Opening statement, witness examination & summation Depositions  Review all depositions & index for access at trial  Create summary of relevant testimony with index to access at trial  Decide how to use at trial. .  Index & make summary of relevant information for use at trial. Decide how to use at trial.

article thumbnail

The Judge's Factfinding Rule (In Jury Trials)

Evidence at Trial

Examples of preliminary facts include the qualification of a witness, the existence of a privilege, and the admission of evidence. The plaintiff wishes to call a witness who will testify that the light was indeed red. The preliminary fact is whether the witness is qualified to testify. 104(b) provides a lower burden of proof.

article thumbnail

“Apex” Depositions of High Government Officials Under the “Morgan” Doctrine

E-Discovery LLC

In the private business context: Not surprisingly, the law surrounding apex witnesses is somewhat indeterminate. The Lambert Court then analyzed the two exceptions, with the burden of proof shifting to the party claiming the exceptions. said Nicole Iannarone, a civil procedure professor at Drexel University Thomas R.

article thumbnail

POLARIZE THE CASE

Temple University Beasley School of Law - Advocacy

When showing a witness’ bias, you need not call them out as a liar; instead, simply argue in closing “and the witness, who testified for the defendant – it’s their mother.” How could a closing not regurgitate the facts, discuss the law and the burden of proof, and anticipate and debunk the opposing party?