article thumbnail

Based on the ESI Protocol, the Limiting “Apex Deposition” Doctrine Applied to Objections to the Designation of a Document Custodian

E-Discovery LLC

It is also not clear to me which party carried the burden of proof under the “apex doctrine.” One recent case placed the burden on the party claiming an exception to the doctrine. However, there may have been practical obstacles, such as geographic location, that may have made use of Rule 45 less favorable. Lambert , __ Md.

article thumbnail

Justices weigh FLSA overtime exemption burden of proof

Legal Dive

A number of federal laws use a preponderance of evidence standard and so should the Fair Labor Standards Act, says the attorney representing the employer in the case.

Insiders

Sign Up for our Newsletter

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

article thumbnail

PROVING THINGS 266: THE BURDEN OF PROOF, HEARSAY EVIDENCE AND WHEN EVIDENCE IS NOT “EXPERT EVIDENCE”: ALSO THE IMPORTANCE OF SERVING A NOTICE OF NON-AUTHENTICITY

Civil Litigation Brief

We are looking, again, at a case where there were issues as to evidence. Part of the defendant's case was that the evidence was not admissible or was hearsay. The defendant's arguments did not prosper. Hearsay is admissible, the real.

article thumbnail

Painting with a Broad Brush: The European Commission’s Failure to Distinguish Seeking Damages for Past Infringement from Seeking an Injunction

IP Watchdog

Previously, we wrote about how alleged concerns of “hold-up” and a lack of “transparency”, two non-legal terms without accepted definitions, are being used to advocate for special rules applicable to patents subject to declarations regarding Fair, Reasonable and Non-Discriminatory (FRAND) licensing.

article thumbnail

Pro Se Renewed Motion for Sanctions is Denied

E-Discovery LLC

Second , the movant failed to carry the burden of proof under Fed.R.Civ.P. 37(e) by clear and convincing proof. Any prejudice he may have encountered due to the delay in production may be remedied by an extension of the discovery deadlines should one be requested. The Court concluded: Viewing Mr.

article thumbnail

Self-Collection, Discovery About Discovery, and Curative Sanctions

E-Discovery LLC

The Burden of Proof However, the Formel court focused on the burden of proof: The Federal Rules of Civil Procedure are silent about which party bears the burden of proving the reasonableness of the steps to preserve ESI. Other courts would place the burden on the party moving for sanctions. … May 26, 2011).

Discovery 130
article thumbnail

CAFC Affirms PTAB Ruling on Motivation and Expectation of Success Over Newman’s Dissent

IP Watchdog

Ethicon on appeal contended that the PTAB improperly placed the burden of proof on them and that the PTAB’s finding of reasonable expectation of success when the asserted prior art was combined was unsupported by substantial evidence. 9,844,379 B2 (the ‘379 patent) were unpatentable as obvious.