article thumbnail

Majority Rules: Supreme Court Revises Standard for Reverse Discrimination Claims

Practice of Law

Courts Dismiss Her Claims Eventually, the district court ruled in favor of the state governments, dismissing Ames’ Title VII claims. The court ruled that Ames did not provide sufficient "background circumstances" to support her claim of reverse discrimination. And it paid off: they revived Ames’ case.

article thumbnail

Fifth Circuit Rules Removing Books In Public Libraries Doesn't Violate First Amendment

Practice of Law

In reaching their split decision on May 23, 2025, the majority of the panel overturned their own precedent from 1995's Campbell v. A federal court ruled that, as government institutions, libraries were subject to First Amendment limitations. Pico (1982). Her wrongful termination suit is still pending.

Insiders

Sign Up for our Newsletter

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

article thumbnail

SCOTUS Agrees To Hear Protester's Challenge to Heck v. Humphrey

Practice of Law

Humphrey as precedent, the city moved for and was awarded a summary judgment. Since Olivier's original conviction was never overturned, the court ruled that he couldn't sue for violation of his constitutional rights when no adjudicated instance existed. Supreme Court Decide Whether To Hear a Case? Using Heck v.

article thumbnail

An Offeror Controls the Terms of the Offer

E-Discovery LLC

In effect, the Majority invalidates a fully executed, integrated settlement agreement based entirely on an excluded hearsay document – a remarkably thin evidentiary reed on which to overturn not only a signed contract but also the trial court’s supported factual findings. In my view, the trial court got it right.”

article thumbnail

EU Court Ruling Limits Meta’s Use of Personal Data for Advertising

Complex Discovery

Editor’s Note: In a recent decision, the Court of Justice of the European Union (CJEU) has set a new precedent for how personal data, particularly sensitive information, can be used in targeted advertising.

article thumbnail

Tie in Supreme Court Ruling Denies Religious Charter School Access to Taxpayer Funding

Practice of Law

While hailed as a victory for proponents of public education and the separation of church and state, the recusal of Supreme Court Justice Amy Coney Barrett might well have kept the lower court's ruling from being overturned. The court ruled against St. Supreme Court. The Patron Saint of What? In 2023, St.

article thumbnail

Protecting the Judiciary and the Rule of Law

E-Discovery LLC

It is also not acceptable to attack the judge making the ruling or try to interfere with the independence of the court. In response to the attacks, the ABA wrote: These statements attack the legitimacy of judicial oversight just because a courts ruling is not what the administration wants in a particular case.