article thumbnail

Court’s Use of a Special Master to Assist EEOC in Obtaining Discovery from Defendant

E-Discovery LLC

45 in connection with a subpoena for LZ’s protected school records. Plaintiff asserted that Genesh “obtained her school records via a subpoena issued in violation of Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 45(a)(4). It added: “Genesh’s clandestine service of the revised subpoena prejudiced [plaintiff] LZ in multiple ways.”

article thumbnail

Application of Work-Product Doctrine to Materials Prepared Years After Incident

E-Discovery LLC

at 4 (citing In re Grand Jury Subpoena , 870 F.3d The Court wrote that: “Conversely, statements taken later… are more likely to contain information otherwise available to the seeking party through its own efforts to obtain statements or to take depositions.” 3d at 317). at *7 (cleaned up; citations and quotation omitted).

Insiders

Sign Up for our Newsletter

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

article thumbnail

Based on the ESI Protocol, the Limiting “Apex Deposition” Doctrine Applied to Objections to the Designation of a Document Custodian

E-Discovery LLC

45 subpoena duces tecum could not have been served on the non-party document custodian and avoided the designation issue. May 5, 2025), For more on the “apex doctrine” outside of the context of document custodians, please see “Apex” Depositions of High Government Officials Under the “Morgan” Doctrine (May 20, 2025). Lambert , __ Md.

article thumbnail

Three Motions for Sanctions Denied Under ESI Rule and Common Law

E-Discovery LLC

The Court pointed to several salient facts: “Curiously, Plaintiff testified at deposition that she had not even retained a lawyer until nearly one month after the call.” “But Efforts to subpoena or depose Mr. Roberts were “thwarted to date by his evasiveness.” Roberts was fired the next day. Again, and as before, Ms.

article thumbnail

Initial Disclosures Cannot Await Expert Opinions

E-Discovery LLC

Vasquez, Blake Lively’s Deposition Pushed Back by 2 Weeks After Judge’s Latest Ruling in Justin Baldoni Case (Jul. Lang, Ruling in Blake Lively’s Subpoena for Justin Baldoni Phone Records (Feb. Italiano, Blake Lively must turn over detailed business income records to Justin Baldoni (Jul. 14, 2025); I. 14, 2025); E. 19, 2025); B.

article thumbnail

Legal Ethics & Malpractice Reporter, Vol. 6, No. 7

Joseph, Hollander & Craft

The law firm found that many of its lawyers were being required to take on collateral activities, such as giving depositions, and were, presumably, having some difficulty being paid for this work from estates.

article thumbnail

What “Expenses” Can a Non-Party Recover for Complying With a Discovery Subpoena?

E-Discovery LLC

20, 2024), the court addressed recovery of expenses by non-parties for responding to a subpoena. 45 (“Subpoena”) states: (b)(1) – Under some circumstances, witness fees and mileage must be paid. [1] d)(3)(B) – A court may, on motion, ensure “that the subpoenaed person will be reasonably compensated.” Fed.R.Civ.P.