article thumbnail

Based on the ESI Protocol, the Limiting “Apex Deposition” Doctrine Applied to Objections to the Designation of a Document Custodian

E-Discovery LLC

Once that was done, the requesting party could identify three more, “subject to limited objections.” It is also not clear to me which party carried the burden of proof under the “apex doctrine.” One recent case placed the burden on the party claiming an exception to the doctrine. 2025 WL 176001, at n. emphasis added).

article thumbnail

Protective Order Barring Use of Discovery Materials in Other Litigation Was Vacated

E-Discovery LLC

Presumably, on remand, the producing party may attempt to meet its burden of proof. The Ninth Circuit vacated the challenged part of the protective order and remanded for further proceedings. Thanks to Daniel Seiden for reporting on this decision. Order Limiting Use of Discovery Post-Case Ruled Too Restrictive (Jul.

Insiders

Sign Up for our Newsletter

This site is protected by reCAPTCHA and the Google Privacy Policy and Terms of Service apply.

article thumbnail

When is a Categorical Privilege Log Insufficient?

E-Discovery LLC

Plaintiff objected, asserting attorney-client privilege, joint prosecution privilege, common interest privilege, and the attorney work-product doctrine. The court noted that the party invoking privilege has the burden of proof and that privileges are construed narrowly. Zafirov , 2024 WL 2846007, at *2.

article thumbnail

“Apex” Depositions of High Government Officials Under the “Morgan” Doctrine

E-Discovery LLC

Defendants objected to the depositions and offered to designate a representative to be deposed in the alternative. The Lambert Court then analyzed the two exceptions, with the burden of proof shifting to the party claiming the exceptions. Plaintiffs/appellees sought to schedule nine depositions.

article thumbnail

Decoding Justice: Key Differences Between Civil and Criminal Litigation

CaseFox

The Burden of Proof : This refers to the responsibility that the plaintiff (the party bringing the case) must demonstrate sufficient evidence of their claims. In the emotionally charged landscape of civil disputes, a professional attorney provides objective advice, making merit-based legal decisions.

article thumbnail

SCOTUS Expands Right to Sue Police Who Bring Baseless Charges

Practice of Law

The burden of proof for the felony money laundering charge was high and contained a “knowledge” requirement. The Malicious Prosecution Suit For the malicious prosecution lawsuit, Chiaverini had to show why the officers did not have probable cause to bring the arrest.

article thumbnail

DON’T WIN THE BATTLE BUT LOSE THE WAR OVER CAUSATION AS A TRIAL ISSUE

Plaintiff Trial Lawyer Tips

The reality is that a jury, following the jury instructions can find significant negligent conduct they object to, but conclude it did not cause the harm plaintiff is complaining about. Review the law with the jury that proof of causation is only to show it is more likely true than not true. See: Washington Pattern Jury Instruction 21.01