Remove Discovery Remove Evidence Remove Rebuttal
article thumbnail

Sanctions Denied Because of Lack of Prejudice, Despite Breach of Duty to Preserve Video

E-Discovery LLC

First , the moving party must establish that there was a duty to preserve potentially relevant evidence. That duty arises “when a party reasonably should know that the evidence may be relevant to anticipated litigation.” Id. Bad faith requires that evidence be destroyed “for the purpose of depriving the adversary of evidence.”

130
130
article thumbnail

“Self Help” Discovery Results in Striking of Wrongfully Obtained Evidence

E-Discovery LLC

9, 2023)(Courts have recognized that sanctions may be imposed for improperly obtaining evidence.). It wrote: Pursuant to its inherent authority, the Court will strike the improperly used material from the pleadings, and Campbell will be barred from using it as evidence in this litigation, except for purposes of rebuttal or impeachment.

Evidence 130
article thumbnail

Town Sanctioned for Prejudicial Breaches of Duty to Preserve in Alleged Sexual Assault Case; Court Also Addresses Use of Personal Email by Council Members

E-Discovery LLC

Discovery had been conducted for almost a year and the deadlines extended three times. Plaintiff seeks limited discovery regarding the missing documents and a negative inference jury instruction regarding the contents of Vanderpool’s and Dupree’s personnel files and the missing emails. 25, 2024)(Sullivan, J.),